Read Baring-Gould’s full account
Baring-Gould’s sources: Ado, Roman Martyrology, also with SS. Nereus and Achilles on May 12th. Authorities: — Dio Cassius, liv. lxvii, and Eusebius Hist. O CASSIUS, the heathen historian (b. 155) says: — “In the same year (a.d. 95) Domitian executed, amongst many others, the consul Flavius Clemens, although he was his kinsman, and was married to Flavia Domitilla, also his relative. Both were accused of atheism (i.e., Christianity) on which charge also many others who had strayed to Jewish customs were condemned, some to death, others to confiscation of goods. Domitilla was, however, only exiled to Pandateria (the isle of Ischia).” The account given by Eusebius differs so materially, that it has been supposed there were two of the name of Flavia Domitilla. He says, “To such an extent did the doctrine which we profess flourish, that even historians that are far from befriending our religion, have not hesitated to record this persecution and its martyrdoms in their histories. These, also, have accurately noted the time, for it happened, according to them, in the fifteenth year of Domitian (a.d. 95). At the same time, for May M 61 Flavia DomitiUa, professing Christ, Flavia DomitiUa, the niece of Flavius Clemens, one of the consuls of Rome at that time, was transported, with many others, by way of punishment, to the island of Pontia."”
Flavius Clemens was cousin germa^n of the emperor^ and was certainly consul in 95. He had two sons, whom the emperor had resolved should succeed him on the throne, and he had changed their names to Vespasian and Domitian [Roman emperor 81–96]. But Flavius Clemens was executed, and his wife, DomitiUa, was banished to Pontia, whilst — so the two accounts are reconciled — his niece Flavia DomitiUa was sent to Pandateria. Domitian was succeeded by Nerva, who died in 98, after a reign of little more than a year, and Trajan [Roman emperor 98–117] mounted the throne. Nerva had recalled the exiles, and — if we may believe the apocryphal Acts of SS. Nereus and Achilles — S. Flavia DomitiUa the younger, the niece of Flavius Clemens, was then at Terracina. Trajan persecuted the Church, and Domitilla was burnt in her house, together with her two servants, Euphrosyne and Theodora. Her eunuchs, Nereus and AchiUes, had already suffered. All this, however, is very questionable as history. For further information we refer to the account of SS. Nereus and Achilles (May 12th.) It is difficult to say whether the S. Flavia Domitilla, commemorated on May 7th, be not the elder saint, who was not a martyr, though, as S. J erome says, her life was one long martyrdom in exile; and the S. Flavia Domitilla, on May 1 2 th, be the younger, if there really were two of this name. It is by no means improbable that Eusebius [Eusebius of Caesarea (d. c. 339), the first historian of the Church] made a mistake, and that this mistake has led to the making of two saints of the same name. The Acts are of no authority. [Mavf.